Home or away: the difference between in-home care and assisted living

The difference between in-home care and assisted living

Article by 

Lucy Pearson

Everything you need to know about the difference between in-home care and assisted living

As our loved ones age, the decision of how to best support them in their later years becomes a significant and often challenging one. And while there’s no one-size fits all approach when it comes to ensuring they’re well-looked after, the two main options that families often consider are assisted living facilities and in-home care. Each choice comes with both benefits and considerations, and making the right decision requires careful evaluation of the individual’s needs, preferences, and – of course – the family’s resources and financial situation.

What is an assisted living facility?

When it comes to the difference between in-home care and assisted living, an assisted living facility is a residential community designed for seniors who need some assistance with daily activities but still wish to maintain a level of independence. These facilities offer a range of services, including help with personal care, medication management, and daily meals. Residents typically have their own private living spaces, which gives them a sense of autonomy.

When considering assisted living, it’s important to take into account the specific needs of your loved one. Assisted living can be an excellent option for those who may benefit from being able to socialise with others at the same stage of life, as these facilities often provide a lively community atmosphere. Group activities, communal dining, and organized outings can contribute to a more active and engaged lifestyle – which is a huge draw for those wanting to retain a sense of independence as they age.

Pros of assisted living:

Community engagement: Assisted living facilities offer a community environment, fostering social interactions and reducing isolation, which is crucial for mental and emotional well-being, particularly as you age. The benefits that this sort of social set-up offer its residents can be huge. And while happy hours and holiday celebrations may not seem like the most obvious component of assisted living – they go a long way towards bolstering the joie de vivre of the folk who reside therein.

Professional assistance: Trained staff are available around the clock to help with everything from daily activities, to correct management of medication, ensuring that residents receive the care they need. This means that family members can relax knowing their loved one’s medication is being properly administered by a on-site professional. It’s also worth noting that most assisted living communities have a system in place to increase the level of care as more help becomes necessary.

Amenities and activities: Depending on the community, many assisted living facilities provide amenities such as fitness centres, libraries, walking trails and organized events, promoting a fulfilling and active lifestyle for residents. Access to these sorts of amenities can not only enhance physical health, mental stimulation, and wellness, but social connections and a sense of community too.

What is in-home care?

In-home care, on the other hand, involves hiring professionals to assist with caring responsibilities within the surroundings of the elderly person’s home. This option is particularly appealing for individuals who wish to grow old somewhere familiar to them, and maintain a sense of ease and comfort.

When considering in-home care, it’s crucial to evaluate the level of care required and the home environment. In-home care can be an excellent choice for anyone with specific medical needs or those who value the familiarity of their home and want to preserve their independence for as long as possible.

Pros of in-home care:

Familiarity and independence: Aging at home gives elderly people the opportunity to stay in the comfort of their own homes, surrounded by familiar belongings and memories, promoting a sense of independence.

Personalized care plans: In-home care services can be tailored to the specific needs of the individual, providing a more personalized and flexible approach to caring. Home care helps with day-to-day tasks such as cooking, cleaning or doing the laundry so that someone can maintain their quality of life as they age.

Family involvement: In-home care allows family members to be actively involved in the care process, providing emotional support, and maintaining close relationships. Unlike an assisted living facility, if your loved one chooses to receive care at home, family members won’t be bound by visiting hours. This is a significant advantage means, which means that maintaining and nurturing familial relationships becomes more convenient and flexible.

Everything you need to consider before making your decision

Health and care needs:

Assess the current and potential future health needs of your loved one. Consider if your loved one requires specialized medical care that can be better provided in an assisted living setting.

Financial considerations:

Evaluate the costs associated with both options, including initial fees, monthly expenses, and potential hidden costs. Compare the financial impact of modifying the home for aging in place with the expenses of assisted living.

Level of independence:

Gauge your loved one’s desire for independence and the ability to maintain it in either setting. Consider the impact of communal living versus staying in a familiar home environment on their overall well-being.

Socialization and activities:

Assess the importance of social interactions and organized activities for your loved one. Consider whether your loved one would thrive in a community setting with access to various amenities and organized events.

Family involvement:

Determine how involved family members can and want to be in the caring process.

Consider the impact of family support on the senior’s emotional well-being.

Choosing between assisted living and in-home care is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of various factors – and rightly so. There is no one-size-fits-all solution, and the right choice depends on the needs and preferences of the elderly individual and their family. By thoroughly assessing health needs, financial considerations, the level of independence desired, socialization preferences, and family involvement, you can make an informed decision that best supports the well-being and happiness of your elderly loved ones. In the end, whether it’s the community-oriented environment of assisted living or the personalized care of aging in place, the goal is to provide a safe, comfortable, and fulfilling life for seniors in their golden years.

Blog Banner 786px x 300px

In Need of Support?

Carer Gateway is an Australian Government program providing free services and support for carers. Call Carer Gateway for support and access to services, Monday to Friday, 8am to 5pm local time.

Assistance with accessing emergency respite is available any time, 24/7.

1800 422 737 

Friends & Partners


Care & Ageing Well Expo Perth 2024

Screenshot 2024 02 19 at 12.38.32 pm